Twenty percent of public schools in the United States use school uniforms in the 2013-2014 school year. School uniforms continue to grow in popularity, even among public schools. Kids around the country face danger from gangs and bullying, school uniforms help to protect kids from bullying and help with the gangs that threaten those kids. School uniforms protect the kids and encourage individuality in ways other than their outward appearance. School uniforms help not only the school but also the students who wear those uniforms.
School uniforms started becoming common in the 19
th century in charity schools in the United Kingdom. Community members donated uniforms and schools started using them to promote school pride and patriotism in the country (Scott). In the United States, schools began using school uniforms during the industrial age to connect the schools to industrialization, capitalism, and show the schools’ national loyalty. Some schools used them to show religion or maintain tradition. The uniforms promoted formality, self-discipline, and patriotism. School uniforms continue to promote unity among the student bodies and students form friendships based solely on the personalities of their peers, rather than allowing the wealth of their peers to influence their opinions.
Now, when people think of school uniforms, they tend to think of private schools, but more and more public schools adopt the idea of school uniforms in efforts to make their school a better environment and help their students excel. School uniforms in public schools “[gain their] first perceptible momentum in 1994 when the Long Beach Unified School District in Long Beach, California [adopt school uniforms] for its … elementary and middle school students” (Huss 31). Most high schools choose not to enforce uniforms, which gives kids the opportunity to still wear what they want to wear. Now, school uniforms tend to appear in cities and more kids attending the schools with uniforms tend to qualify for free and reduced-price lunches (Fast Facts). The schools want to make all their students equal to their peers and uniforms allow for their equality. Since school uniforms tend to appear in private schools and areas with a lot of poverty, so people tend to associate them with the rich and the poor, rather than all ages and levels of wealth. Parents worry about sending their kids to a public school with uniforms because they think it “is an unsafe place to send their child” (Walmsley 65). Even if the uniforms make the schools safer, they schools get a reputation of danger because of the schools’ environment before uniforms. Parents choose not to consider the safety of the schools after getting uniforms and assume that the schools continue putting the students in danger. More public schools need school uniforms so that parents feel safe sending their kids to a school with uniforms.
School uniforms protect children from gang presences and make violence less prevalent in schools. Gangs usually utilize colors or insignias to show who belongs to their gang. One mother shares the story of how a gang spares her sons’ lives because of their school uniforms. Four men point guns at her sons and demand to see their shirts, since “they [do] not have on any red or blue; they [are] dressed in in uniform—a white shirt and tie and black/grey pants” (qtd. in Brunsma 82), the gang allows them to live. If kids choose to wear the wrong colors, gangs might threaten their lives. Uniforms help prevent that. In the first four years of school uniforms in the school district of Long Beach, California, crime drops ninety-one percent, weapon offenses drop ninety-two percent, drug charges drop sixty-two percent, overall attendance reaches an all-time high, and overall test scores rise (Cruz 36). Schools in the area that never implement school uniforms never experience the same changes. The school in Long Beach becomes safer and a better learning environment for the kids. The uniforms also make it obvious when possible danger walks through the doors by identifying “non-enrolled, truant students… and other outsiders” (Alleyne, LaPoint, Lee, Mitchell 425). When all of the students wear that same things, faculty easily recognizes people who could endanger the students. Kids stay safe because they wear uniforms, and they become better students and people.
With school uniforms teachers notice a change in the behaviors of students. Students show more responsibility with school uniforms. Students focus on their education, rather than “’jone-ing’ [competitive, back and forth verbal bantering] on individuals in class” (Alleyne, LaPoint, Lee, and Mitchell 423). The students focus more during class and choose to work on their school work, not goof around with their classmates. When the kids stop goofing off in class, they learn more effectively and thoroughly. Along with less goofing around in class, school uniforms reduce “teasing, absenteeism, and school violence… [and] increase students’ confidence, pride, and self-esteem” (Alleyne, LaPoint, Lee, and Mitchell 424). School uniforms make the teachers’ jobs easier, the students more focused in class, and the students feel responsible enough to attend class and make it to class on time. The students show more respect towards their teachers and other adults. The kids who wear uniforms “are less cocky towards adults… better behaved—less attitude” (Huss 36). Uniforms make students more responsible for their actions. Uniforms also prepare kids for when they go to work and follow a dress code or wear a specific uniform (Alleyne, LaPoint, Lee, Mitchell 420). In their futures, a lot (if not, all) of those kids face uniforms or dress codes that they will need to follow in their jobs, and the school uniforms get them more comfortable with the idea of uniforms, and prepare them for their futures and jobs. School uniforms help kids in their futures and make them into better people.
School uniforms promote a better learning environment for the students, helping the teachers with their jobs. With school uniforms, schools experience “’fewer classroom disruptions’ and ‘fewer incidences of quarreling’… the school takes on a quieter, studious atmosphere” (Huss 36). The students behave better when in uniform, preparing to learn, rather than disrupting school and wasting time. Kids in school uniforms also tend to out-perform the non-uniformed students on standardized testing (Bodine 69). The kids’ more productive learning becomes obvious during standardized testing because of higher test scores. The atmosphere that uniforms provide helps the kids learn better and motivate them to focus and respect their teachers and the other people they encounter in their daily lives.
Parents worry about the financial burden of school uniforms, but in the long run, school uniforms save money. Parents, rather than buying new clothes for their children whenever fashions change, only buy school clothes once for the whole year, only needing to buy replacements. In the United Kingdom, all schools, even public, require school uniforms and “parents appreciate needing to buy only a few shirts, a few trousers, skirts, tights, and possibly a blazer, cardigan, or sweatshirt for the entire school year” (Walmsley 64). In comparison to the clothes that kids normally want for school, parents end up spending a lot less money with school uniforms. When Angela Walmsley, a parent and teacher herself, moved to the UK and sent her kids to school there, she notices how she “[spends] less money and [needs] far fewer items of clothing for [her] children when they [wear] school uniforms” (64). Her observation includes the clothes that her kids wear outside of school. The kids need less clothes for at home and the weekends, so the parents spend less money. Once more schools utilize uniforms, the prices also lower. In the UK, where all schools require uniforms, so many places carry those uniforms that they become a lot cheaper due to the demand for the uniforms and the competition for the sales (Walmsley 64). The high demand helps to lower prices, so if more schools get uniforms, they become more affordable for all families. With uniforms, parents pay less throughout the year for new clothes and more easily afford other things. Uniforms become preferred for all people involved, students included.
Students tend to dislike the idea of school uniforms initially, but eventually they prefer school uniforms. Students see how they put everyone on an equal playing field. Students face an inability to judge based on how people dressed, which shows their wealth, because all the students wear the same thing. Students no longer tease their peers with remarks like “didn’t you wear that yesterday?” because they all wear the same as what they wore the day before. Ms. Flanagan, a teacher at a school that adopted a policy of school uniforms (name not disclosed), notices how the girls in her class display less “catty” characteristics with school uniforms (Huss 36). They no longer pick on their peers because of their clothes, since the school uniforms took that opportunity from them. The kids feel pride in wearing their uniforms and kids start to feel excited to go to school because of an increase in school spirit (Huss 36). The kids enjoy wearing the uniforms and see how they benefit them, so even upon getting the opportunity to not wear uniforms, many choose to wear the uniforms. A principal from Houston’s students even petition for wearing uniforms. That fall, “out of 1,800 kids… twelve report not in uniform” (Cruz 39). Those students fight for school uniforms and, with their parents, implement school uniforms for their district. Rather than choosing what to wear each day from their closet full of options, they know their options right away, so they grab their uniform and go. They eliminate a lot of the prep time in the morning for kids, as one student from San Antonio points out (Cruz 39). Kids enjoy the ease of the uniforms and how uniforms positively impact the school’s environment.
Some people worry about uniforms turning the kids into “uniform minds,” but uniforms promote individuality in ways other than outward appearances. Uniforms make all of the kids equal, but they promote each child to act how they want to act and let their personality grow. Other kids see their peers as equal, and they bully less, which allows kids to let their personality shine. Those uniforms make the kids feel like they belong (Huss 32). Since the kids feel like they belong, they act how they would when most comfortable. Normally, kids hide their true personalities in a normal school setting. The kids make friendships based on personalities, rather than allowing how their peers dress to impact their opinion of those peers. Thus, their relationships with others improve and make the school better (Huss 32). While school uniforms make kids look the same, the kids still act based on their personality, which makes them into their own individual and makes them happier with their school.
Many people think that school uniforms cause little change in the safety and academic environment of schools. They see dress codes as more beneficial as school uniforms, but dress codes end up taking more time away from teaching. “One principal said he spends 60 to 90 minutes each day dealing with dress code issues” (qtd. in Walmsley 66). The time that teachers and administrators deal with dress code violations takes away from the students’ learning and causes more time where students sit in class before the teacher starts teaching. Dress codes allow students to dress in similar ways as normal; Dress codes limit little of what the students wear, so the possibility exists that they still wear clothes showing their connections to gangs. With school uniforms, school administrators interpret necklaces, like Harrison County’s Ryan Green’s Star of David necklace, as gang symbols (Cruz 23). Kids feel attacked because of teachers trying to uphold dress codes and get rid of the influence of gangs. Even if the symbols hold no connection to gangs, faculty still see some of the students’ clothes as gang related. School uniforms eliminate this problem. Dress codes also limit the clothes that students wear so that, often, wearing clothes that show pride in their race or religion gets them in trouble, like with Ryan Green’s Star of David. Students who choose to wear “t-shirts with messages such as ‘the blacker the college, the sweeter the knowledge’ [receive] warnings from the school’s administration” (Cruz 25). When those kids show pride in their race, they face trouble with their schools’ administrators. Even if school uniforms still prohibit kids wearing shirts like that to school, the kids never face punishment for showing pride in themselves and their race. While dress codes work in some schools, they bring problems along with them that cause more frustration in comparison to school uniforms and the frustration that they bring.
Even with all of the concerns about school uniforms, they help the kids and schools turn into the best versions possible. Kids prepare for their future and become more respectful towards others, while learning more productively. School uniforms reduce violence at schools and help identify possible dangers in their school. Schools provide a clear guideline of what they allow kids to wear, which keeps the kids and teacher in class. School uniforms help kids and if more schools implemented those uniforms, the bad stigma surrounding them would disappear.
Works Cited
Alleyne, Sylvan I., Velma LaPoint, Jennifer Lee, and Harold
W. Mitchell. "Black Educators' Views on Middle School Students' Dress and Uniforms:
Addressing Challenges from Commercialism." Journal of Negro Education vol. 72, no. 4, 2003, pp. 418-426. JSTOR. Web. 29 Mar. 2017.
Bodine, Ann. “School Uniforms, Academic Achievement, and
Uses of Research” The Journal of
Educational Research vol. 97, no. 2, Nov./Dec. 2003, pp. 67-71. Academic Search Premier [EBSCO]. Web. 29
Mar. 2017.
Brunsma, David L. The School Uniform
Movement and What It Tells Us about American Education: A Symbolic Crusade.
Lanham, MD: ScarecrowEducation, 2004. Print.
Cruz, Bárbara. School Dress Codes: A
Pro/Con Issue. Berkeley Heights, NJ: Enslow Pub., 2001. Print.
"Fast Facts." National Center for Educational
Statistics. US Department of Education, 2015. Web. 30 Mar.
2017. <https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=50>.
Huss, John A. "The Role of School Uniforms in Creating
an Academically Motivating Climate: Do Uniforms Influence Teacher
Expectations?" Journal of Ethnographic and Qualitative Research vol.
1, 2007, pp. 31-39. Academic Search Premier [EBSCO]. Web. 29 Mar. 2017.
Scott, Jenny. "School Uniforms: A History of 'rebellion
and Conformity'." BBC News. BBC, 05 Sept. 2014. Web. 30 Mar. 2017.
<http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-29047752>.
"Uniforms,
School." Encyclopedia of Clothing and Fashion. Encyclopedia.com.
28 Mar. 2017 <http://www.encyclopedia.com>.
Walmsley, Angela. "What the United Kingdom Can Teach
the United States About School Uniforms." Kappan Magazine, Mar.
2011, pp. 63-67. Academic Search Premier [EBSCO]. Web. 29 Mar. 2017.